Time Is Wobbly: Living With the Telescoping Effect

Two summers ago, my neighbor swore he’d lent me his hedge trimmer “last month.” I remembered it as last fall. We both felt so sure that we shrugged, checked text messages, and ate our humble pie. It was May. We were both wrong, and for opposite reasons. He felt the loan was closer than it was. I felt it was farther away. That tiny, everyday wobble in time perception isn’t a glitch in your calendar app. It’s a feature of human memory called the telescoping effect.

In one sentence: the telescoping effect is the tendency to remember recent events as more distant and distant events as more recent than they actually are.

We’re the MetalHatsCats Team. We’re building a Cognitive Biases app because we keep tripping over the same mind-warps ourselves—especially this one. When time gets stretchy, we make bad calls. We double-book. We swear “it’s been ages” when it’s been six days. We guess wrong on customer timelines and blow project retros. This article is our field guide to stop that.

What Is the Telescoping Effect and Why It Matters

If you’ve ever looked through a telescope, you know it makes far-off things feel closer. Memory does that, too, but with a twist. The telescoping effect has two directions:

• Forward telescoping: distant events feel more recent than they are. You “pull” the past forward.
• Backward telescoping: recent events feel more distant than they are. You “push” the recent past back.

We do both. Often in the same week.

Why we do it:

• Memory isn’t a timestamped database. It’s a reconstruction. When you recall, you rebuild the story from fragments—images, words, feelings, other events. In the rebuild, time slips a little. That slip often leans toward neatness and coherence rather than accuracy (Rubin, 1996).

• We anchor on landmarks. “Right after my trip,” “before the election,” “around the product launch.” These landmarks slide in your mind. You adjust the event to the landmark, not the calendar, and the adjustment accumulates.

• Life compresses. Repeated or routine days blend ("work-gym-dinner" blur). Sparse, unique events expand. The brain smooths the timeline like a mapmaker simplifying a coastline. Less detail? The brain guesses the shape.

• Ego and emotion tilt the scale. We often pull pleasant or identity-boosting events closer (“I go to the gym all the time—just went!”) and push unpleasant ones away (“That argument? Ancient history”). Not always, but often (Brown, 1990).

Why this matters:

• In surveys and research, telescoping inflates or deflates event rates. People overreport recent usage or underreport gaps. You think your users did X “in the last month” when they did it three months ago (Neter & Waksberg, 1964; Bradburn, Rips, & Shevell, 1987).

• In medicine, patients misdate symptoms. “This cough started last week.” Actually three weeks. That changes diagnosis paths.

• In teams, postmortems lose the thread. Decisions look earlier or later, causes attach to wrong effects, and lessons drown.

• In personal life, time budgeting collapses. You think you called your mom “recently.” It was 10 weeks. You believe you haven’t taken a break “in forever.” It was on Tuesday.

Time isn’t just a schedule. It’s a scaffold for meaning and decisions. If the scaffold leans, so does everything you build on it.

Examples: Short Stories From a Wobbly Clock

We learn best when it hurts a little. Here are cases we’ve seen or lived. Try to spot which direction the telescope pulled.

The Marketing Memory Slip

A startup founder tells a new investor: “We launched the retention campaign right after the pricing change.” In her mind, it’s tight: change, spike in churn, campaign fixes it. When the analyst checks the timeline, the campaign started six weeks before the pricing shift. Backward telescoping snuck in. The founder compressed prior work into a tidy arc and misassigned credit. They almost doubled down on the wrong lever.

Takeaway: when stakes are high, timestamps beat stories. Stories still matter—but tie them to logs.

The Doctor Visit Drift

A patient reports to a primary care doctor: “I’ve had this abdominal pain for a week, off and on.” The doctor asks follow-ups and senses uncertainty. They check the patient portal. The patient messaged about the same pain twenty-one days ago. Plan A (watchful waiting) becomes Plan B (ultrasound and labs). Forward telescoping (pulling the older pain forward) would have delayed care. The timeline changed the diagnosis.

Takeaway: pull records when you can. If you can’t, trace anchor events (“before/after holidays? birthdays?”).

The “We Just Deployed” Mirage

An engineer swears the big deploy was “last sprint.” The bug they’re examining feels tied to that ship. In the repo, the merge happened three sprints ago, quietly. Another hotfix came five days ago and is the true suspect. The memory locked onto a salient event and dragged everything around it toward “recent.”

Takeaway: don’t trust artifacts in your head when you can open the actual artifacts.

The Relationship Loop

A couple argues about date nights. “We never go out anymore,” says one. “We literally went out last weekend,” says the other. They check photos. The last outing was four weekends ago. Backward telescoping made something feel far away; forward telescoping made something else feel near. Both partners were sincere. The calendar broke the stalemate.

Takeaway: evidence softens arguments. Not because you win, but because you stop guessing.

The Fitness Exception You Keep Remembering

A runner feels on track. “I ran a long one last weekend.” The tracker says 15 days. The memory filled the space with a hazy “recent.” Why? The run was emotionally vivid—perfect weather, new route—so the brain pulls it closer. This can go the other way with bad workouts you want to banish into “long ago.”

Takeaway: value your vividness. Don’t let it con you.

The Subscriptions That Time Forgot

A friend swears he canceled his streaming trial “right after the free month.” He didn’t. Five months later, he notices the charge. The act of deciding to cancel (mental action) replaced the act of actually canceling (physical action). In memory, he did it. In reality, he meant to. The intention telescoped forward to become an event.

Takeaway: if it matters, complete the loop. Then take a screenshot.

The Tax Receipt Shuffle

You think you donated to a charity “this year.” Turns out it was last December. Or you think last year’s donation happened “around spring,” so you wrongly claim it this year. Charities often see spikes in late-year giving that people remember as January or February because those months better fit a “fresh start” narrative.

Takeaway: store your receipts the moment you receive them. Date, amount, how paid. Boring beats penalties.

The Project That Felt Faster Than It Was

A designer tells a client, “We finished the homepage revamp a few weeks ago.” It was nine weeks. Work with many small launches feels like one flow. The brain compresses the routine. Only the “final” milestone sticks, and even that slides.

Takeaway: if you bill by phase, track. If you scope by phase, track. Your feelings will under- or over-sell reality.

The “I Called My Parents Yesterday” Trap

You feel like you just checked in with family. The chat thread says two emojis last Tuesday and a proper call a month ago. Social closeness telescopes. When you feel close, time shortens; when you feel guilty, time lengthens. Both directions distort.

Takeaway: set recurring reminders with checkboxes. Let completion, not mood, tell you the truth.

The Witness Timeline Tangle

A bystander to a fender-bender tells police the SUV “pulled out moments after the light turned green.” Video shows eight seconds. Under stress, people often compress time, and they place events nearer or farther from salient anchors (the light changing) than they actually were (Loftus, 1979). Those shifts influence fault.

Takeaway: in stressful events, collect independent timestamps quickly—photos, logs, cameras—before memory hardens.

Recognize and Avoid the Telescoping Effect

You don’t have to become a robot. You need habits that ground your stories to time. It’s less about distrusting yourself and more about building friendly guardrails.

Build External Memory

Write where you can’t fib to yourself. Not because you’re dishonest. Because you’re human.

• Use a calendar like a camera. Drop a 10-second note after anything you might need to date later: “Met Jae re: hiring plan,” “Started cough,” “Pushed v2.3.1.” No sentences, just fragments.

• Snap mundane photos. If you don’t journal, take a photo of your whiteboard, running shoes, or pill bottle. Photos time-stamp effort.

• Save receipts to a single place. Email forwarding helps. “Fwd: Donation to BrightMind.” Create a rule: all receipts go to one folder.

• Adopt “If it wasn’t logged, it didn’t happen.” Not forever, not for everything. For the things you argue with yourself about: workouts, bills, releases.

Anchor Smarter

If your brain loves anchors, feed it better ones.

• Use shared public anchors with fixed dates: holidays, product launches, school terms, weather events. Ask: “Was it before or after the snowstorm?” Vague anchors like “around summer” invite drift.

• Bracket with two anchors, not one. “Between Lena’s birthday and the Portland trip” is tighter than “around the trip.”

• Walk backward from today. “Yesterday, last week, two weeks ago…” helps you feel the chunks rather than guess the whole.

Decompose the Event

Big events hide smaller events. Smaller ones date better.

• Break the story. “We rolled out the campaign” turns into “approved copy,” “uploaded creatives,” “set budget live,” “first spend.” One of those has an exact date.

• Separate intention from action. Ask, “When did we decide?” and “When did we do it?” Put both on the timeline.

• Name the first irreversible step. That date matters more than a kickoff meeting you can move or a soft launch you can roll back.

Use Bounded Recall When Asking Others

If you lead teams, survey customers, or interview users, the structure of your questions either triggers telescoping or guards against it.

• Shorten the window. “In the last 7 days” is more accurate than “last month.” “Since last Wednesday” works best if you can tie it to a fixed date.

• Provide a calendar during interviews. Show a simple month grid and mark public events. Ask people to point.

• Decompose frequency. “How many times did you do X last week?” outperforms “How often do you do X?” Add the “When exactly?” follow-up.

• Use checklists instead of free recall when possible. People forget; checklists nudge memory without leading.

Trust Artifacts First, Vividness Second

Emotion helps memory stick but bends its placement.

• Grab the closest artifact: message thread, repo commit, photo EXIF, step count, door camera logs, flight confirmations.

• Switch to “artifact mode” the moment two people disagree. No posturing. Just curiosity: “Let’s check.”

• Keep your artifact map handy. Know where your truth lives: calendar, notes, issue tracker, banking app, health portal. Make them searchable.

Create Rituals That Replace Guesswork

Behavior beats cleverness. Build routines that default you to accuracy.

• The “Friday File.” Every Friday, spend 10 minutes filing the week: tag calendar entries, drag receipts, jot high/low. No prose, just bullets.

• The “After Action Ping.” After any meaningful event, send a one-line message (to yourself, a teammate, a channel). “Shipped 2.3.1 with fix for auth.” It timestamps and informs.

• The “Before I Say It, I Check It” rule. In meetings, if someone asks “When did we…?” and you feel a guess rising, say, “Give me 30 seconds.” Open the repo or calendar. You’ll be the reliable one.

Notice Feelings as Signals, Not Facts

Your emotions color time. Don’t fight them. Label them.

• If you feel shame, expect backward telescoping (“It’s been forever since I did X”). If you feel pride, expect forward telescoping (“I just did Y!”). Adjust your estimate in the opposite direction or, better, check.

• When an event fits your identity story, double-check its date. “I’m a consistent runner” is powerful. It also invites “recency blur.”

• When days feel like oatmeal, lean on structure. Remote work and sameness compress weeks. Your calendar becomes your memory.

Related or Confusable Ideas

Telescoping often shows up with other time and memory quirks. Here’s how to tell them apart and where they overlap.

• Recency bias: you weigh recent information too heavily. Telescoping is about misdating; recency bias is about overweighting. They can tag-team: you think an event is recent and also give it extra weight. Different levers, similar trouble.

• Planning fallacy: you underestimate how long future tasks will take. Telescoping often distorts the past, which then feeds the planning fallacy. “We shipped the last feature in two weeks” (it was six), so you plan two weeks again.

• Hindsight bias: after an event, you feel like you “knew it all along.” Telescoping can reorder or compress the path to a result, making the inevitability feel real.

• Duration neglect and peak-end rule: when judging experiences, we focus on the peak and the end, not the duration. Telescoping moves the peak closer or pushes the end away in your story.

• Rosy retrospection: we recall the past as better than it was. Telescoping may pull those rosy events closer, intensifying the glow.

• The reminiscence bump: we recall more from adolescence and early adulthood. It’s about which memories survive, not how we date them. Still, those vivid early memories often feel recent, which is a telescoping effect on top of a recall bias.

• Time dilation under stress: in emergencies, time feels slower or faster in the moment. Telescoping happens after the fact, when you file and retrieve the memory.

• Source confusion: you mix up where a memory came from (a dream, a story, a show). Telescoping is about when it happened, not where it came from—but they mingle in messy situations.

If it helps, think of telescoping as calendar-error and the others as weighting, editing, or selection errors. They stack. They also yield to the same tool: artifacts.

Wrap-Up: Make Time Solid Again

Most days, time is a fog we pretend is concrete. We misplace good things and bad things, wins and losses. We compress drudgery, stretch joy, and slide dates to fit our stories. This isn’t a moral flaw. It’s a side effect of being a human who doesn’t carry a calendar in their skull.

You don’t need to fight your memory. You need to befriend it. Give it anchors. Give it proof. Give it rituals so small and boring they outlast mood. The payoff is soft and loud at the same time. Soft: fewer petty arguments, less guilt, more grace. Loud: better decisions, cleaner retros, clearer roadmaps, fewer costly “I thought that was last week” mistakes.

We built the bones of our work life on telescoped memories for years. It made us charming storytellers and sloppy timekeepers. Now we’re building a Cognitive Biases app to help ourselves—and you—spot patterns like this in real time. We want a tiny nudge that says, “Check the artifact,” or “Bound the window,” or “That’s a backward telescope talking.” Because tiny nudges beat big regrets.

Time is wobbly. That’s okay. We can steady it together.

—MetalHatsCats Team

• Neter & Waksberg (1964). A Study of Response Errors in Expenditures Data.
• Bradburn, Rips, & Shevell (1987). Answering autobiographical questions: The impact of memory and inference on surveys.
• Rubin (1996). Remembering our past: Studies in autobiographical memory.
• Loftus (1979). Eyewitness Testimony.

References (light touch):